🥾 ActiveWeekend · from New York, NY
Fire Island: Sunken Forest & Atlantic Surf
Fire Island is the most accessible wilderness barrier island in the US — a 32-mile Atlantic-facing sand barrier with no paved roads, no private cars, and a National Wilderness Area that takes 15 minutes to reach by ferry. The Sunken Forest in the Sailors Haven section is a unique holly-and-sassafras forest that exists at sea level behind the dune line; the ocean beach is one of the few undeveloped Atlantic beaches within 50 miles of Manhattan.
Day 1 — Fire Island, NYDay 2 — Fire Island Lighthouse & Kismet, NY
Day 1 — Fire Island, NY
Day 1 — Fire Island, NY
🚗 1 hr 15 min driving📍 7 stops
🌅
Morning
🚗
Drive
New York, NY → Bay Shore Ferry Terminal
1 hr 15 min8:00 AM → 9:15 AM
Drive east via Southern State Parkway to Bay Shore.
Fire Island — Sailors Haven Ferry
★ 4.6A 25-minute ferry from Bay Shore to Sailors Haven on Fire Island — the National Park Service ferry that runs from May to October. The crossing traverses the Great South Bay; the approach to the island shows the single dune line between bay and ocean, the width of Fire Island at its typical half-mile cross-section.
9:15 AM📍 See location
🍽️
Lunch
Sunken Forest
★ 4.8A unique holly-and-sassafras forest behind the Fire Island dune line, preserved at sea level because the dunes block the salt spray that would otherwise prevent tree growth. The 1.5-mile boardwalk loop through the Sunken Forest passes through a closed-canopy forest of American holly, shadblow, and sassafras with a root system visible above the soil surface. The forest is a National Natural Landmark.
10:15 AM📍 See location
Sailors Haven Beach & Visitor Center
★ 4.6The ocean beach at Sailors Haven is one of the few Atlantic beaches in the New York metro area with no development behind the dune line — the dunes rise 15-20 feet above the beach, and the view from the surf faces open ocean to Spain. The lifeguarded beach is active July through Labor Day; the National Park Service visitor center has exhibits on barrier island ecology.
11:15 AM📍 See location
Rachel's Bakery & Restaurant
★ 4.3A Fire Island staple in Ocean Beach serving breakfast and lunch all day — omelets, pancakes, sandwiches, and lobster rolls in a casual beachside setting. The neighborhood hub for Ocean Beach visitors since 1984.
12:15 PM📍 See location
☀️
Afternoon
Ocean Beach Village
A 25-minute walk east along the beach from Sailors Haven leads to Ocean Beach — the only commercial village on Fire Island with a main street of restaurants, bars, and shops. The village has no cars; the main street is foot traffic and red wagons (the island's standard luggage transport). The Ocean Bay Market has been serving the island year-round since 1910.
1:15 PM📍 See location
🌙
Evening
Matthew's Seafood House — Ocean Beach
★ 4.2A Fire Island institution on Bay Walk in Ocean Beach, serving fresh-caught seafood — fried clams, lobster rolls, grilled striped bass — in a casual outdoor setting facing the Great South Bay. The sunset view from the bay-side deck across the Great South Bay to the Long Island south shore is the best light-show on the island.
5:00 PM📍 See location
🛏️
Clegg Hotel
The island's only year-round hotel in Ocean Beach on Fire Island, operating since 1939.
Day 2 — Fire Island Lighthouse, Kismet & Atlantique, NY
Day 2 — Fire Island Lighthouse, Kismet & Atlantique, NY
🚗 2 hr 15 min driving📍 3 stops
🌅
Morning
🚗
Drive
Ocean Beach → Fire Island Lighthouse
25 min8:00 AM → 8:25 AM
Walk or take a water taxi west from Ocean Beach to the Fire Island Lighthouse area at Democrat Point — about 2.5 miles on foot or a short water taxi ride. No cars on the island.
Fire Island Lighthouse
★ 4.8The 1858 lighthouse at the Fire Island Inlet — 168 feet of black-banded granite, the tallest lighthouse on Long Island, accessible via a 1.5-mile boardwalk from the Robert Moses State Park parking area. The lighthouse museum in the restored keeper's quarters traces 200 years of Fire Island maritime history; the view from the lantern room encompasses the entire barrier island, Robert Moses Causeway, and the Atlantic.
8:25 AM📍 See location
🍽️
Lunch
🚗
Drive
Fire Island Lighthouse → Kismet
15 min9:25 AM → 9:40 AM
Walk east along the bay path from the lighthouse area to Kismet — roughly 1.5 miles on foot. No cars on the island.
🍽️ Lunch9:40 AM
Kismet — The Surf Club
The Fire Island hamlet of Kismet is the westernmost ferry stop, with a character distinct from the commercial villages to the east — smaller, quieter, and oriented toward families and day visitors. The Surf Club is the village's central deck bar, with frozen drinks and pub food served above the bay at the ferry dock.
4 options · tap to switch
☀️
Afternoon
🚗
Drive
Kismet → Atlantique
20 min12:00 PM → 12:20 PM
Walk east along the ocean beach from Kismet through Ocean Beach to Atlantique — about 2 miles on packed sand. No cars on the island.
Atlantique — National Seashore Beach
★ 4.8The undeveloped stretch of ocean beach between Kismet and Ocean Beach passes through the Fire Island National Seashore wilderness — no lifeguards, no facilities, and a beach width of 300-400 feet at low tide. Horseshoe crab nesting is active in June; piping plover nesting areas are marked and avoided. The wilderness walk (4 miles round trip) is the most isolated Atlantic beach experience in the New York metro region.
12:20 PM📍 See location
🌙
Evening
🚗
Drive
Atlantique → New York, NY
1 hr 15 min5:00 PM → 6:15 PM
Take a water taxi or ferry east from Atlantique to the Bay Shore terminal, then Southern State Parkway west to New York.
Plan your own escapeExplore more trips →